Monday, June 6, 2016

Community Policing for the Bangsamoro finally come up with a Toolkit

By Jun Enriquez

Community Facilitators attended the Community Policing Toolkit Launch at Crowne Plaza, Pasig City, March 15, 2016, 
Iligan City (May 31, 2016) - The Bangsamoro armed struggle started since Marcos regime in the early 1970s by the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF) led by Prof. Nur Misuari. In August 1, 1989, Republic Act 6734 or the Organic Act of the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (ARMM) was signed into law and was amended through RA 9054, the expanded ARMM of 2001. In September 2, 1996, Peace agreement was signed by the Philippine government and the MNLF during the Ramos Administration. Due to the dissatisfaction of the signed agreement, the newly formed Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) broke away from the MNLF and continued the Bangsamoro struggle in Mindanao. The Philippine government started talks with the MILF in 1997 and on the same year signed a ceasefire agreement to continue the talks.
In March 2000, an all-out-war broke out during the Estrada Administration started in Kauswagan, Lanao del Norte. In April 2003 another armed conflict broke out started in Bulioc complex in Maguindanao during the Arroyo Administration. In  August 2008, the MILF waged armed confrontation against the Government started in Maguindanao in protest of the failed MOA-AD still under the Arroyo Administration. All of these armed conflict escalated all over south and western Mindanao. Since the start of the Bangsamoro struggle, an estimated of 120,000 lives lost with at least 3 million people displaced and Billions of pesos damaged in properties.

In the year 2010, President Benigno Aquino III continued the Peace talks with the MILF. In October 15, 2012, the Framework Agreement on the Bangsamoro (FAB) was signed by the Philippine Government and the MILF followed by the signing of the four Annexes on Normalization, Power sharing, Wealth sharing and Transitional Arrangement and Modalities including the Addendum on Bangsamoro waters.      

In March 27, 2014, the Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro  (CAB) was signed by the Philippine government and the MILF that ended hardships in negotiations for 17 years. The Bangsamoro Basic Law (BBL)/Bill if signed into law will replace the RA 9054, the expanded ARMM. The CAB and massive consultation with the people is the basis for crafting the BBL which later changed to Basic Law on the Bangsamoro Autonomous Region (BLBAR). Normalization as one of the annexes of the FAB is taking into consideration on security issues in the Bangsamoro. One of the provisions in the Normalization is the Police force for the Bangsamoro for law enforcement and maintenance of peace and order. In the draft BBL, the Community policing is stated under Article 11 Section 11 of the original version of the BBL stating among others “the Bangsamoro Police shall adopt Community Policing as an essential mechanism in maintaining peace and order”.  The Philippine Government has existing mandate on PNP concerns, the R.A. 6975. An Act Establishing The Philippine National Police Under A Reorganized Department of The Interior And Local Government, and For Other Purposes. “… the State shall bolster a system of coordination and cooperation among the citizenry, local executives and the integrated law enforcement and public safety agencies” (Section 2, Declaration of Policy)

                        Facilitators' training in Davao City, April 21-22, 2015.


In response to this, some of the peace advocates and civil society groups in Mindanao expressed their interests to initiate information and education campaign project on Community Policing in partnership and supported by the British Council and Security Reform Initiative (SRI), the main proponents behind the project on Community Policing in the Bangsamoro. It is funded by the UK Government's Golden Thread Community Policing Project. SRI as the national secretariat of Bantay Bayanihan, an oversight network of the Internal Peace and Security Plan (IPSP)-Bayanihan of the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) – Bayanihan, tapped CSO partners for the conduct of the community policing project in seven (7) provinces of North Cotabato, Maguindanao, Lanao del Sur, Lanao del Norte, Sulu, Basilan and tawi-tawi.

Feedback session in Rogongon, Iligan City, April 16, 2016.


Community Policing project is implemented in five (5) phases. First is Baseline study to gauge the level of knowledge in the community on the concept of community policing, and to understand how the participants currently view their law enforcers. Second is Awareness phase focused on raising awareness of the basic concepts and principles of community policing. It aims to prepare the communities for a greater involvement in shaping and taking part of their own community policing through the later consultation process. Third is the Consultation Phase, the communities were asked to define the specifics on how the participants want community policing to be implemented in their area. Indigenous policing mechanisms or policing techniques that may be unique yet effective in their areas were likewise surfaced. Fourth is Community Policing Strategy and Toolkit is developed based on the results of the earlier phases of the project and lessons drawn from international best practices. Working alongside the implementing CSO partners is a Technical Working Group (TWG) composed of representatives from the Philippine National Police (PNP) Headquarters – Directorate for Police Community Relations, PNP Police Regional Office – ARMM, Philippine Public Safety College, Armed Forces of the Philippines – Peace Process Office, National Police Commission, Department of the Interior and Local Government – ARMM, Moro Islamic Liberation Front, Security Reform Initiative, Conciliation Resources, and British Council. Fifth is the Feedback Phase closes the loop. The Toolkit will be presented to the communities to inform them of how their ideas and inputs were considered and included in the crafting of the Toolkit.

Feedback Session in Kolambugan, LDN, April 15, 2016

There are five (5) elements of Community policing. First is Service Delivery, Community policing is service oriented wherein the community is the client and the police is the service provider. The delivery of this service is best done through a collaborative partnership with the community. Second is Partnership, Community policing is a partnership whose objective is to determine community needs so that policing priorities can be responsive to those needs. This means that both the community and the police should become partners in creating a safe and secure. Third is Problem solving, is key to community policing. After identifying the problem together, the communities can now tell the problem to the police without the community and the police criticizing each other but rather joining heads in trying to provide solution. It also means working together in implementing the solution. Fourth is Empowerment, Community policing is an agent of empowerment, creating a sense of joint responsibility and a joint capacity for addressing issues and concern to the campus community and police personnel. This will require training about community policing so everyone has a constructive role.  Fifth is Accountability, in community policing, accountability is achieved by making the provider responsible to the client, creating mechanisms through which the police are accountable for addressing the needs and concerns of the community they serve.

Feedback session in Munai, LDN, April 23, 2016. 
In Lanao del Norte (LDN) province, there are four (4) identified model communities and implemented the Community Policing project in the municipalities of Munai, with dominant Moro people; Tagoloan, mix with Moro and non-Moro community; Kolambugan, dominant with Christians community; and Rogongon, Iligan City, dominant with the Indigenous people, the Higaonon tribe community.  Bantay Kalilintad (BK) network implemented the community policing project in Lanao del Norte, the local partner of Security Reform Initiative (SRI) with the head facilitator, Ms. Cristina Lomoljo, Executive Director of Balay Integrated Rehabilitation for Total Human Development (BIRTHDEV). BK implementing partners include the Civil Society Organization Forum for Peace (CSO-FP), Ranao Disaster Response Rehabilitation Action Center (RDRRAC), Pailig Development Foundation, Inc. (PDFI), Institute of Peace and Development in Mindanao (IPDM), among others.  

Facilitating team discussed the Toolkit in Tagoloan, LDN 

The Bantay Kalilintad facilitators’ team in Lanao del Norte has conducted the “Kapihan with Champions” on February 29, 2016 at Villa Lacida Beach resort, Linamon, Lanao del Norte, Attended by the LGU representatives, CSO leaders and community leaders. Kapihan is a safe space where key stakeholders of the community are gathered to know about the Community Policing project on its basic concepts, principles and practices.  This activity aimed to update key stakeholders on the results and status of the Community Policing project in the Bangsamoro; to gather valuable insights and ideas from the local champions and identify their crucial roles in the conduct of the Community Policing project; and to draw support and commitment from key stakeholders.

Feedback session Iligan City by the SRI, April 27, 2016.

It was informed that Baseline results has a total of 767 participants from 17 different towns in 6 different provinces answered the baseline survey on Community Policing (CP). Respondents reported never having heard of CP (60%) not knowing the meaning of CP (66%), never having been consulted about it (79%), and not being able to name any of its elements (79%). In the Awareness results, a total of 1,178 participants from 29 communities in 6 provinces were able to attend the awareness sessions. Consultation Phase: A total of 1,071 participants took part in the consultations in the 27 communities. The participants came from key sectors, these include farmers, women, religious organization, indigenous people, senior citizens, people with disabilities, academe, students, barangay peacekeeping action teams (BPATs), members of the barangay local government unit, and members of security sectors.

Participants Feedback session in Tagoloan, LDN, April 24, 2016
Kapihan participants expressed their views that the partnership of the police and community should work together to assure peace and order. Barangay justice system is existing practice with the presence of “Lupon Tagapamayapa” is a big help in community policing to settle minor differences amicably to prevent full blown commission of crime. There are some organizations championing on tri-people familiar with the traditional practices on “Rido Settlement” also a big contribution in community policing. Documentation process is very important to know the root cause of conflict. Some Local government units have created Municipal Arbitratry Community (MAC), composed of Bagy chairman, traditional leaders, Municipal officials, relatives of conflicting parties. Police and LGU are active in Municipal Peace and Order Council (MPOC) to discuss peace and order situation. There are non-uniform personnel (NUP) in the police force to gather intelligence report and combat crimes. Drugs still present but need to undergo due process (law standards). The most important is to inform and educate the people about community policing. Barangay Peacekeeping Action team (BPAT) is organized in almost all of the LGUs. Some of the religious sector are members of “Oplan lambat sibat”, a PNP program on volunteering on peace and order, part of community intillegence. The ratio of police to people is 1:1,000. It was suggested that Community Policing results will be presented to the Peace and order council (POC) in city, municipal and provincial level. Some Women organizations have organized women empowerment on Justice and healing and VAWC  at Barangay level.
Facilitators' training in Davao City, April 22, 2015.
In March 15, 2016, a Community Policing Dissemination Forum and Public Presentation and Toolkit Launch at Crowne Plaza Galleria Manila, Ortigas Center, Pasig City. In the presentation, the main focus of Community Policing is inclined to the five (5) Elements accompanying the Toolkit. First is the Service Delivery, it aims few important features leading a move away from the traditional model of policing; second is Partnership, tailoring policing based on local norms, values and individual community needs; third is Problem solving, shifting patrol from time-to-place based on problem analysis and community need; fourth is Accountability, translating philosophies and strategies into concrete actions; and fifth is Empowerment, empowering of police and communities that allows the citizens to share decision making and responsibilities with the police. The technical Working Group (TWG) composed of 12 members decided that the accompanying Toolkit would be set against a measure that included the Philosophical, Strategic, Geographical, Tactical and Organizational dimensions of Policing.

                        Mr. Phillip Thomson (standing) facilitated the Facilitators' 
                        training in Manila, March 15, 2016.



Mr. Phillip Thomson, Team Leader of the Community Policing of the United Kingdom, in his statement said that there are many examples of Community policing around the world from which to draw international best practice and from which templates can be formulated. Thomson added “This project has fundamentally always about people and their aspirations concerning the style of policing they wished to have, so finally and most importantly I would wish to thank the people of the Bangsamoro for their enthusiasm and active participation in this project and the people and the Government of the United Kingdom represented by Her Majesty’s Ambassador Asif Ahmad for making this project possible”.    
                        Mr. Nicholas Thomas, Country Director, British Council (left) 
                        & Ms. Kathleen Tolosa, Executive Director, Security 
                        Reform Initiative, signed the contract on Community Policing
                        project April 21, 2015, Davao City.

Mr. Nicholas Thomas, Country Director, British Council, in his statement said that the British Council aims to promote a friendly knowledge and understanding between the people of the UK and people worldwide, making a positive contribution in all of the countries where they operate, and a lasting difference to the UK’s security, prosperity and influence. The British Council’s Community Policing Project, implemented in partnership with Security Reform Initiative (SRI) and the Bantay Bayanihan network is a central part of their work to support the development of a more open, prosperous and inclusive society in Mindanao.

Series of Feedback sessions on the Community Policing (CP) Toolkit were conducted  in Lanao del Norte in April 2016 in the municipalities of Munai, Kolambugan and Tagoloan, all of Lanao del Norte, and Rogongon, Iligan City. Another Toolkit presentation in Iligan City was conducted on April 27, 2016 with participants from the PNP and Military. There are 74 practical steps placed in a matrix that can be operationalise the 5 key elements, the Service delivery, Partnership, Problem solving, Accountability and Empowerment and serve as a guide in the implementation phase. In the matrix questions ask, “What will we do?” and “Why will we do it?” link to the CP Elements and Ethos or operating standards.  However, there are 54 items which are considered inputs with ownership of results coming from the provincial consultations concerning the issues such as police visibility, cultural awareness, Police station friendly to the victim, police in proper uniform and posture, professionalism, local police officer accessibility, among others.

An open forum during the Feedback sessions in Lanao del Norte and Iligan City have raised some questions from the participants such as, “This is intended to solve problems but it did not focus on the biggest problem which is the rampant use of illegal drugs, why?” the facilitators answered, “It is mentioned as one of the possible joint efforts considered by the community working together with the Police. Just to emphasize that this (Toolkit) is a guide and it will be detailed upon formulation of the actual mechanism in solving particular problems. Other insights, “It is good if implemented properly.” Others still questions the future implementation and said “We have no doubt about the capacity of the Police but the question is, are they contented to follow these (Toolkit) guidelines?”. Additional feedback from a Teacher, “I am thankful that our ideas are included in the toolkit and we can outright claim our contribution in the development of Community Policing Toolkit.” Some police participants reacted that most of the items in the Toolkit was already in effect but the facilitators informed the participants that the Toolkit is the product of the community consultation for the past six months.

 Ms. Kathleen Tolosa, Exec. Dir., SRI, April 21. 2015, Davao City.

Ms. Kathleen Tolosa, Executive Director, Security Reform Initiative (SRI), in an interview during the Toolkit launching by the Radio live direct from Iligan City said that the Community Policing Toolkit is the product over a six-month period. Scoping and designed activities were conducted to ensure that the project was fit for its purpose. Its objectives is to improve community awareness and understanding on Community Policing; Conduct inclusive community consultations to inform the Community Policing  strategy development; and Develop a robust Community Policing blueprint and toolkit for use and adoption by key authorities and institutions. Ms. Tolosa extends her thanks to the British Council for the successful implementation of the project, the United Kingdom Government through the Golden Thread fund support for Community Policing, the British Embassy in Manila provided direct support for the peace negotiations through the International Contact Group, the Bantay Bayanihan and SRI partners in Mindanao and other stakeholders for the actual implementation of the project in the seven (7) provinces in Mindanao and lastly the Technical Working Group (TWG) for making the Community Policing Toolkit possible.



No comments:

Post a Comment

Popular Posts